I liked the spoolie it separates the eyelash and it stays on all day and I think they have the washable kind so I would recommend getting that one because when it come to making water proof mascara Maybelline does Screw around but yeah both washable and water proof are handy to keep around.

I had a question about whether to buy the brn/blk or very blk- yep it's me:) Well I bought the brn/blk (waterproof)and I use an eye lash curler before (!)and define a lash(waterproof), then this ( you got to be fast or it looks clumpy). My lashes look really full and wouldn't leave the house w/o my combo;). I got so many compliments! My dad thought I had false eyelashes on..lol! So yes this works, and washes off w/ my Olay remover...or you can use a towelette-be gentle! The only thing is after about 6 hours you look like you've been to a party if you put to much on so only use one swipe per eyelash; try to do the above (curl, define a lash,the falsies) and you should look great!:P

i loved this..... i put it on and the first swipe i had the longest lashes in the world. i loved this product. i am so glad that i bought this product. i was thinking about telling everyone that i knew but they already knew! I hope that more people use this product....

I bought this mascara recently, and the first time I tried it, it wasn't horrible,but it also wasn't great. The packaging says that its supposed to volumize your eyelashes, and it didn't. It definitely doesn't look like false eyelashes, it just looks like an average cheap mascara. Two days later, it got extremely clumpy. I tried wiping the brush and removing the clumps, but it was still clumpy. Not only that, but there wasn't much mascara in the bottle. It also didn't even last long either, it barely showed that I had mascara on 1 hour after applying it. Waste of money!

I really like this product! It makes lashes very long and full, and I even got compliments from 2 of my friends on how long my lashes were! To be more specific, one stated "Why are your lashes so fat?" (that was a guy... obviously) and the other simply said "I like your eyelashes". My natural lashes are SUPER short (literally, they're like little stubs) and this mascara made them really long! The only bad thing I have to say about it is that it dried up really fast. Like, in four weeks. But all well, it worked great!!!

Stays on really good. I've always worn waterproof mascara, but before I bought this one, I read the reviews on it and it got pretty high reviews. Like so many others out there, I wore the Cover Girl "Marathon Eye Mascara"for YEARS until they discontinued it - and I never have been able to find anything that came close to it (and I've bought a lot of mascaras and wasted a lot of money over many, many years) but this one really is pretty good - it's still not like our Marathon Mascara, but closer than anything else I've tried so far. Give it a try!

I love love love this mascara...MUST buy the Waterproof for max. results! Also, It means waterproof, so you will need a quality eye makeup remover for this stuff. I love to try new products when they come out (product hopper), but after wearing Falsies...I wont be wearing any other mascara. I did try 2 other mascaras after using falsies and there was no comparison. Awesome product!

This mascara is fantastic!! It works so well, does not smear, and stays on until you take it off. Make sure to use micellar water to remove it. It'll come off so easy with micellar water. I use Garnier SkinActive Micellar Cleansing Water All-in-1 Waterproof.

I buy waterproof mascara because it doesn't rub off under my eyes throughout the day. This does. So, on top of being hard to remove at night(which, of course, all waterproof mascaras are), it somehow also doesn't stay on my lashes. Sort of a bizarre paradox. Won't be reordering.

i bought this because it was on sale and i wanted my eyelashes to look longer. The first few days the mascara was perfect but, ever since then it has been clumping a lot. I still use it sometimes but after applying Define a Lash. Don't get me wrong it does make your lashes longer but doesnt go on easily.